What’s Your Theory?

Lesson Plan

Lesson

Close observation helps students see tiny details in the Grip Enhancers (Menuki) with Rats, the Grip Enhancers (Menuki) with Wasps and Fans and the Sword Guard with Plum Blossoms and Snowflakes. They will use these details to engage in different visual arts and writing activities, where they will be able to design their own sword guards or grip enhancers using symbols important to them.

Intended Age Group

Elementary (grades K-5)

Length of Lesson

One 50 minute lesson

Standards Area

Visual Arts

Objectives

Students will be able to:

  • describe at least four details of each object;
  • develop and articulate a clear theory about the use for each object;
  • work comfortably in a small group;
  • explain at least two of the symbols on the objects;
  • create at least two symbols based on elements in their culture; and
  • design their own sword guard incorporating symbols they’ve created.

Lesson

NOTE: This lesson plan can be adapted to use any or all of the objects listed.

  1. Warm-up: Have students study a picture you select that contains a great number of details. After two minutes, take the image away and ask the students to write down as many details as they can remember. Have them get with a partner and add items to their lists that they didn’t remember.
  2. Show the students the pictures of the sword guard. Don’t tell them anything the object, what it is for, etc. Tell them to work individually or in groups of 2-3 to write out at least five different theories about the use for the item.
  3. After 3-5 minutes, tell the students that the item is part of a larger object. Allow them a couple more minutes to brainstorm. Have the individuals or groups get with another group and share their theories; they need to offer explanations about why they came up with their theories and write them on the board or posted sheets of butcher paper.
  4. After talking about their theories, share the Samurai Sword Fittings diagram with the students. Make certain the students are clear on where each object was placed and why it was placed there.
  5. Ask them why they think the sword guard and grip enhancers were made with such craftsmanship and attention to detail. Have them critique the pieces, talking about design, layout, and overall flow of each. What do they like? Why? What do they don’t like? Why?
  6. Using the About the Art information, go into more detail about the Samurai warriors. Also discuss the snowflakes and falling petals in the Snow Guard and the role of rats in the Asian zodiac, mochi, wasps, rats and fans in the Grip Enhancers and point out other details as you talk. Share that the students are going to have the chance to design their own sword guards or grip enhancers.
  7. Have the students think about symbolism from their own cultures/religions, or make up their own symbols to incorporate in designs for their own sword guard or grip enhancers. They should compose a brief write up about the symbols they choose.
  8. Have them make preliminary sketches of their sword guard or grip enhancers, then ask them to share their designs with one or two other people and talk about ways in which they could change or improve what they are trying to do. Make sure they don’t focus too much on how the images are drawn but rather what images they have chosen to communicate their ideas and how they are laid out in the design.
  9. Allow them additional time to finish their artwork and then post in a gallery fashion around the classroom. Tell everyone to pick one set of grip enhancers or one sword guard to explore that does not belong to someone they consulted with during the initial critique. They are to develop a theory about the symbolism of the design. They should also identify three things they really like about the design and why.

Materials

Standards

CO Standards

  • Visual Arts
    • Invent and Discover to Create
    • Observe and Learn to Comprehend
    • Relate and Connect to Transfer
    • Envision and Critique to Reflect
  • Language Arts
    • Oral Expression and Listening
    • Research and Reasoning
    • Writing and Composition
    • Reading for All Purposes

21st Century Skills

  • Collaboration
  • Critical Thinking & Reasoning
  • Information Literacy
  • Invention
  • Self-Direction

About the Art

Sword Guard with Plum Blossoms and Snowflakes

Sword Guard with Plum Blossoms and Snowflakes

Edo period (1800s)

Yushusha Isshi, Japan

Who Made It?

This sword guard—called a tsuba [SUE-bah]—was made by Yushusha Isshi [you-SHOO-shah EE-she] during Japan’s Edo period. At the age of 15, Isshi became part of the Goto school. When a craftsman became a part of a “school” like the Goto school, it meant that he was trained by craftsmen who had experience creating pieces in the style of the Goto family. As the official group of craftsmen to the most powerful samurai leader in Japan, the Goto family made various items that were part of a properly outfitted sword, including sword guards. Under the guidance of Goto Ichijo [GO-toe ee-CHEE-joe], who is considered the last great craftsman of the Goto family, Isshi learned the Goto family’s secrets to working with metal and helped the head of the school craft pieces for customers.

Sword guards were originally made by the same artisans who made sword blades, but by the Edo period, many of the pieces that accompanied the blade were made by a separate specialist or group of specialists. By the time these sword guards were made, Isshi had mastered the ability to work with different metals and combine them in a single object. He used an inlay technique to create this sword guard, which involves embedding a soft metal, like gold or silver, into a harder metal. His skill at working on a small scale is evident in the details seen on this sword guard.

What Inspired It?

Sword guards served as both functional and decorative items. They were initially created to be hand guards that separated the blade of a sword from the handle. A sword guard prevented the warrior’s hand from sliding onto his blade as he thrust his sword forward. It also could protect his hand from an enemy’s sword .The guard also balanced the sword’s center of gravity and gave the warrior greater control over his weapon.

The Edo period (1603–1868), when this sword guard was made, was largely a time of peace. During this time sword guards became much more ornamental as opposed to functional. Artisans developed new styles of carving and inlay, and used special materials like gold, which was less practical than the iron that was used previously because it is a softer metal. The guards were often the most decorative part of a sword and reflected changes in fashion. Expensive and beautiful sword guards showed wealth and good taste. A samurai warrior often owned several sword guards and would change them, along with the other fittings, based on the occasion. He wore his sword with the guard placed at the center of his body, making it visible to others.

This sword guard is decorated with flower blossoms on one side and snowflakes on the other. Falling blossoms shown at the end of their life are often a symbol of what the Japanese call mono no aware [MOE-no no ah-WAR-ay], which means “the sadness of things.” This concept indicates a sensitivity to the fleeting nature of beauty. The short life of the blossoms has often been associated with mortality, and is sometimes thought to mirror the life of a samurai warrior. The snowflakes may be another reference to something that lasts only a short time.

A sword guard is part of a sword’s fittings. The fittings included the hilt (handle), the scabbard (blade cover), the tsuba (sword guard), and menuki (grip enhancers).

A diagram of a samurai sword’s fittings:

Samurai Sword Fittings Diagram

Another sword guard in the Denver Art Museum’s collection:

Sword Guard of Bamboo and Tiger

Two examples of grip enhancers in the Denver Art Museum’s collection:

Grip Enhancers (Menuki) with Rats

Grip Enhancers (Menuki) with Wasps and Fans

Details

Flowers
Flowers

The flowers could be either plum or cherry blossoms. Both types of blossoms are significant in Japanese culture. Plum blossoms are associated with the start of spring and often serve as a protective charm against evil. They are traditionally planted in the northeast portion of a Japanese garden because that is the direction from which evil is believed to come. The Japanese eat pickled plum to prevent misfortune. The cherry blossom is the national flower of Japan. Though the blossoms are no more beautiful than those of other flowering trees, they are highly valued because they usually disappear within a week of first blooming. They are often seen as a symbol of the ephemeral nature of life and are frequently depicted in art. They are an omen of good fortune and represent love and affection.

Falling Petals
Falling Petals

Four single petals seem to float randomly around the blossoms. Imagine how easy it is for the slightest breeze to tear a delicate petal from a flower and carry it away. These falling petals emphasize the short life of the blossoms.

Snowflakes
Snowflakes

Snowflakes do appear in Japanese art, but not as often as flower blossoms. Using an inlay technique, Isshi embedded silver to create the snowflakes on this sword guard. They are similar to real snowflakes in that they all have six arms and are all unique. However, the arms of a real snowflake are all about the same length, while the arms of the snowflakes on the sword guard differ in length. This causes us to wonder: Did the artist actually examine real snowflakes when making this sword guard? We are not sure how to answer this question because although some characteristics of a real snowflake are portrayed correctly, others are not.

Signature
Signature

You can see the signature of the artist on the side with the flowers. The artist made the signature by cutting into the metal—a technique called incising. In many cases, the side with the signature is considered to be the front of the sword guard. The front faces away from the warrior carrying the sword; it is the side that others see.

Metal
Metal

The body of this sword guard is made from shibuichi [she-boo-EE-chee], which is an alloy (mixture) made of 75% copper and 25% silver. It is sometimes called “dusky silver” because it is not as shiny or bright as pure silver. If you look carefully you can see that some parts of the snowflakes and blossoms are brighter, which may mean a more pure form of silver was added to the surface of the dusky silver in these areas.

Gold
Gold

Gold is used to form the stem of the two-blossom group as well as the centers of the flowers. There are tiny gold dots that look like gold dust scattered around the flowers on one side and around the snowflakes on the other. The broken clouds on the side with the blossoms reveal a crescent moon that is also made of gold. Gold is not very durable, so seeing it here tells us that this sword guard was made to be used during times of peace, almost as a piece of jewelry, rather than as a functional hand protector.

Shape
Shape

Sword guards can be any number of shapes, but they are usually round or oval. This sword guard is not quite oval; its edge is somewhat wavy, creating four lobes or projections.

Funding for lesson plans provided by a grant from the Morgridge Family Foundation. Additional funding provided by the William Randolph Hearst Endowment for Education Programs, and Xcel Energy Foundation. We thank our colleagues at the University of Denver Morgridge College of Education.